"The shock from that is ridiculous," he said.
Evelyn Faye Pillow was convicted of assaulting an infant she was babysitting for last year. The 85-year-old Henrico woman admitted in court Friday that there's enough evidence to convict her, without admitting guilt.
"I think that something else was in play before this occurred," said Lynchesky. I don't think all the information was given forth."
Medical experts had planned to show that the infant had signs of shaken baby syndrome. When the child became unresponsive last year, Pillow called the family of the baby and 911.
Pillow was sentenced to 12 months behind bars with all 12 months suspended.
CBS 6 asked legal expert Todd Stone if that punishment was typical for this kind of crime.
"Usually with shaken baby cases you see the tragic ending where the baby actually dies and here the baby recovered and I think that made a huge difference," said Stone.
The conviction has shocked several neighbors living on Pillow's street.
"That's just disheartening," said one neighbor.
Lynchesky still said that something just doesn't add up.
"She watched my child for about for years straight and she still sees my daughter whenever we can," he said.
Lynchesky said he never had any suspicions of Pillow, describing his neighbor as caring.
"Very well kept, very polite," he said.
He said despite the controversy, he's sticking by his neighbor's side.
"She's a good woman and I think that something like this might have been a mistake or something bad could have happened prior that we don't know," he said.