Federal judge dismisses state from $40M lawsuit filed by UVA student

RICHMOND, Va. — A federal judge dismissed the state from a $40 million lawsuit filed by a 20-year-old UVa.student wrongly accused of buying beer.

Judge Henry Hudson heard arguments from both the state and one of the attorneys representing college student Elizabeth Daly. Daly, now 21, sued more than half a dozen agents with the Virginia Alcoholic Beverage Control.

Daly was arrested in April 2013 following an undercover ABC operation in Charlottesville. State officers mistook her sparkling water, purchased inside a grocery store, for beer.

Daly’s attorney argued the plain-clothed agents jumped his client, as she tried getting inside her SUV. As a result the lawsuit includes allegations of assault and battery against the officers.

Daly’s attorney, James Thorsen, said the assault against his client — although not physical– resulted in a “mental injury.”

Assistant Attorney General Catherine Hill fired back and said the nearly 50-page complaint from Daly was full of dramatization. Hill added Daly was the one in the wrong on April 11, 2013 when she resisted the agents and hit several of them with her SUV as she drove off.

Daly was arrested after the incident and charged with assaulting the officers she grazed with her vehicle. Those charges were later dropped.

The judge dismissed two of Daly’s claims, where the state was named as failing to train and supervise ABC agents. However, several more counts remain against the seven agents named in the lawsuit.

Judge Hudson plans to issue an opinion on the remaining claims within two weeks.

11 comments

    • 55Camper

      I agree “Chock-full” is the proper phrase but still doesn’t make sense in this context. Which is it Ms. Hill, facts or drama in Daly’s complaint?

  • mbaker9105

    Glad the State is off the Hook, it would just be you and I paying anyway, but these “Agents” need some punishment. Even though the lawsuit is basically silly. They should lose their jobs, their ability to ever carry a weapon again, be convicted of a misdemeanor or similar, have to write a letter of apology to each student and pay to have it published in every major paper in the state, and be forced once a month to wear or hold a sign outside the state capitol at least once a month for 10 years that says “I used to have a Badge until I abused my authority”.

  • daryl johnson

    What do you expect from a federal judge. They are not about seeking justice. Why not let it go to a jury.

  • Johnnie G

    Outrageous decision. The 40 mil was a bit steep, but there should have been some compensation and the “agents” should be fired.
    Virginia is so corrupt.

  • Bill

    The state is circling the wagons to protect poor police work and worse saying we have to right to resist even an illegal search. The judge needs to re – read the Constitution.

Comments are closed.

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 1,775 other followers