Fatal police-involved shooting
Captured: Dad accused of murdering teens

Fugitive on ’15 Most Wanted’ list arrested for 2002 murders of ex-girlfriend, sister

NEW YORK – One of the U.S. Marshals 15 Most Wanted, a man accused of gunning down his sister and then his former girlfriend, was arrested Tuesday.

Andre Neverson was arrested Tuesday afternoon. He allegedly killed his sister and a former girlfriend in 2002.

Andre Neverson, now 54, was deported from the U.S. in 2000 after he shot a girlfriend's uncle five times. But he came back into the county illegally several months later and, in 2002, allegedly shot his sister in the head and stomach.

Neverson allegedly abducted his former girlfriend the next day. A man walking his dog found Donna Davis' body in East New York two days later on July 11, 2002. She'd suffered with a gunshot wound to the head.

Davis, who was working on a degree at the time, had apparently broken off the relationship shortly beforehand, according to NYPD reports at the time.

Donna Davis

Neverson was seen several times in New York after that. In November of 2002, armed with a gun, he climbed through the window of an ex-girlfriend's home. Neverson said he didn't want to hurt her; he just wanted to see his 2-year-old daughter.

He was gone by the time NYPD officers and U.S. Marshals arrived on scene.

"He's a player," detectives said at the time. "He's a very resourceful individual."

Neverson was arrested in Connecticut around 3:45 p.m. Tuesday. Before this, he was most recently spotted in 2005 in Trinidad.

He is currently awaiting a transfer to New York City.