VA blames ‘confusion’ for misstatements about deaths

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.

The Department of Veterans Affairs apologized on Thursday for causing “confusion” in communicating about the number of deaths caused by delayed care at its medical facilities, but said “there was no intent to mislead anyone.”

In a statement to CNN, the VA said two separate reviews were “intertwined in written and oral statements leading to confusion. … VA inadvertently caused confusion in its communication on this complex set of reviews that were ongoing at the time. For that, we apologize.”

Earlier this week, House Veterans Affairs Committee Chairman Jeff Miller accused the agency of “what appears to be an attempt to mislead Congress and the public” by manipulating its account of the number of deaths.

In a letter to the VA, Miller accused officials of giving questionable information on a fact sheet distributed to his committee at a briefing in April and consistently repeating that information in congressional testimony and to journalists.

Erroneous info repeated

The VA initially said it discovered 23 veterans had died after reviewing 250 million cases dating to 1999. It actually reviewed only 11,000 cases over a much shorter period, from 2010 to 2012, which may indicate there could be more deaths than what the agency has reported.

Even former VA Secretary Eric Shinseki repeated the erroneous information during a news briefing on Capitol Hill.

“We went back in time 15 years. Out of that, we probably looked at 250 million consults. That was narrowed down to 76 institutional disclosures, of which there were 23 deaths that had occurred,” Shinseki said.

His comments came about two weeks before he resigned in May under pressure over the scandal over delayed care and findings that VA schedulers manipulated patient wait times.

Obama signs VA overhaul

The VA apology comes on the same day President Barack Obama signed into law a $16 billion measure to address problems at VA medical facilities.

Miller slammed the VA’s response.

“Even though landmark VA reform legislation has been signed into law, it seems the same sort of dishonesty and deception that caused the VA scandal is continuing unabated at the Department of Veterans Affairs,” Miller said in a statement.

“In briefings to congressional staff, in congressional hearings and in discussions with the media in April, top VA Central Office officials omitted key facts about a review of delays in VA care.

“VA officials let this false impression fester for four months until they were confronted about the scheme by Congress and the media. The department is now attempting to chalk all this up to a misunderstanding, but that explanation doesn’t pass the smell test,” Miller said.

He added that it was “a blatant attempt to mislead Congress, the press and the public, and we will not let it stand.”

Miller said new VA Secretary Robert McDonald must find out who was behind it and fire them.

Investigations of VA

CNN has been investigating and publishing reports of wait lists and deaths of veterans across VA hospitals across the country for nearly a year.

Since August 2013, CNN has repeatedly requested records from the VA through the Freedom of Information Act, but the agency so far has not provided many key documents.

A recent report compiled by the office of Republican Sen. Tom Coburn of Oklahoma found that more than 1,000 veterans might have died in the past decade as a result of malpractice or lack of care from VA medical centers.

At his confirmation hearing in July, McDonald vowed to transform the embattled federal health care system.

“The seriousness of this moment demands urgent action,” McDonald wrote in his testimony.


  • b48rqc1

    Am I a statistic or a “harmless error” by the Veterans Administration Health Care System?

    The diagnosis was that I needed a triple bypass and an evaluation of my heart valve.

    My heart surgery was put on the fast track and scheduled for late March, 2011. The result was a “successful” quadruple bypass and a bovine aortic valve replacement.

    Beginning in mid-July of 2011, I began experiencing lower back pain on the left side. It became increasing more severe. I finally decided to go to the emergency room at McGuire Veterans Hospital located here in Richmond, Virginia. The ER doctor examined me and her suspicion was an intestinal issue. I was treated and released.

    I was diagnosed six weeks later with an abscess between T-8 and T-9 vertebrae caused by the MRSA (Methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus) bacteria that colonized in my spine. The abscess was putting pressure on the spinal nerves and needed to be removed. McGuire Veterans Medical Center performed a laminectomy on my spine and I have not walked since the surgery.

    Below is an excerpt of my progress notes dated 09/21/2011 on page 630:

    Epidural abscess & Back pain: The source is probably the bovine valve which was replaced in March [30th, 2011] since there is no other obvious cause of abscess in this otherwise healthy gentleman. No history of pneumonias or admissions for sepsis. No hx of IV drug use.”

    Clearly, the progress note points the smoking gun back towards the “bovine valve” that was implanted at McGuire Veterans Medical Center five months earlier.

    I have been placed in a veterans’ nursing home as a paraplegic, cast aside like waste, destined to die a slow and heartbreaking death, alone, at the hands of the Veterans Administration.


Comments are closed.

Notice: you are using an outdated browser. Microsoft does not recommend using IE as your default browser. Some features on this website, like video and images, might not work properly. For the best experience, please upgrade your browser.