Awkward? Girl who sued parents returns home

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.

(CNN) — A high school senior who filed suit against her mother and father for financial support and college tuition has returned to her home in Lincoln Park, New Jersey, the attorneys for her parents said Wednesday.

“Rachel Canning has returned home and reunited with her parents and siblings. Her return home is not contingent on any financial and/or other considerations,” said the statement from the law firm Snyder & Sarno.

The lawsuit has not officially been dropped, but Angelo Sarno, who is representing Rachel’s parents, Sean and Elizabeth, said the family conflict has been resolved.

“The bottom line is it’s over,” Sarno said at a news conference. “It’s ancient history, it’s done. They’ve welcomed her back into the house.”

Canning, 18, alleged in her lawsuit that her parents forced her out of their home and that she was unable to support herself financially. The lawsuit asked that her parents pay the remaining tuition for her last semester at her private high school, pay her current living and transportation expenses, commit to paying her college tuition and reimburse her friend’s parents for legal fees.

Her parents said she left home because she didn’t want to obey their rules.

A judge last week denied the teenager’s request for high school tuition and current living expenses from her parents. A date had been set for April on the other issues in the lawsuit.

Canning, an honor student and cheerleader at Morris Catholic High School in Denville, said in court documents that she had to leave her parents’ home because of emotional and psychological mistreatment. She alleged, among other things, that her mother called her “fat” and “porky” and that her father threatened to beat her.

Canning was suspended from school for truancy in October, according to court documents filed by her parents’ former attorney, Laurie Rush-Masuret. Her parents told the teen that she could no longer see her boyfriend, who was also suspended from school. Car and phone privileges were also taken away. Once she learned of the punishment, Canning cut school again and then decided to run away, her father said in court documents.

After receiving allegations that Rachel was being abused, New Jersey’s Division of Child Protection and Permanency interviewed the teen, her parents and her two younger sisters, but they ultimately “determined that allegation of emotional abuse was unfounded,” a letter from DCPP states.

Neither Rachel nor her parents were present at Wednesday’s news conference. Sarno would not comment on what brought the reconciliation or whether Rachel was still in a relationship with her boyfriend. He asked that the public respect the family’s privacy.

“This is a matter that should have been brought into some counselor’s office, not into a courtroom,” Sarno said. “We just ask that you respect their wishes and give them some chance to resolve it.”

CNN’s requests for comment from Tanya Helfand, the attorney representing the younger Canning, were not returned. A request for comment from John Inglesino, whose family had been paying Rachel’s legal fees and housing her for the past four months, also was unanswered.

In court documents filed in New Jersey Superior Court Wednesday, Helfand wrote that only a few days ago, Rachel indicated that she could not go back home. But after speaking with her mother Tuesday, she decided to waive the complaint.

If Rachel wishes to dismiss the lawsuit, it should “be done of her own free will and not due to the extreme pressure of her parents and the media,” Helfand wrote in court documents.

Canning’s case attracted national attention, which Sarno noted would likely continue to affect Rachel. He said the family is not expected to make a public statement, despite the amicable resolution.

“Nothing good could have come from this case. Absolutely nothing good. This kid is going to be affected long term from the attention,” Sarno said.


  • Margie Olson

    Oh please…………….A rich kid with wealthy parents!! The girl should be ashamed of herself, wasting the time of the courts when there is more needy cases out there of Abuse. Just a poor rich girl who didn’t get her way. There is no sympathy for the kid. There is countless cases of Abuse against children in this country and to use the basis of any abuse to get her way is SICK!! The parents must be Morons to even raise a child to think they can use the system and lie so badly to all.
    This kid is a ZERO in my books. The real ones deserving the Help is children who are not heard and left to be Abused.

  • Scarlett Cross

    Margie, child abuse is not relegated to the poor or middle classes. Before you make a judgement, hear all of the facts. I doubt if it’s the case here but it has and does happen among the wealthy too.

    • athynz

      Having followed this story from the beginning not only here but via other news sources as well I can say there was indeed abuse – abuse of the mother and father by that harridan of a daughter! There was a voicemail that the daughter – evidence that was admitted to court and released to the public – left where she said she wanted to defecate on her mother’s face…

      That being said you do have a point that child abuse is not limited by one’s socieconomic status, race, religion, etc.

  • Norma

    Excuse me scarlett, but I have to say I disagree totally about you saying that girl was abused by her parents! if anyone was doing the abusing was HER to her parents! How can someone say they were being abused and get everything they ever wanted? food, clothes, room and board, a car, money, and everything else? only the kids who are spoiled that’s who! She wanted what she wanted and when she didn’t get it she got vindictive and chose the latter. please o a little research on this scarlett, because it just might happen to you, that’s if u have any children.

  • Nicole

    I actually have to agree with Scarlett. I had a great friend in high school who had everything a girl could want whose mother was physically and emotionally abusive. So much so, my friend hung herself a little while after senior year. So wealth does not determine if abuse is present. Abuse is abuse regardless of your bank account.

  • Nicole

    That being said, I don’t know this girl from Adam and am not commenting on this story; just the previous comments.

Comments are closed.