Lottery winner exhumed after rare cyanide death
By Jen Christensen, CNN
(CNN) — The body of an Illinois lottery winner was exhumed Friday by the Cook County medical examiner’s office after toxicology results showed he died of cyanide poisoning.
An autopsy will be performed on Urooj Khan’s body to determine how cyanide wound up in his system. Murder by cyanide poisoning is extremely rare, experts say.
Khan died in July, the day after the lottery issued him a check for about $425,000 after taxes. He won the money playing a scratch-off game a month earlier.
“We are investigating it as a murder, and we’re working closely with the medical examiner’s office,” Chicago police spokeswoman Melissa Stratton said last week.
On the day Khan died, he ate dinner and went to bed, according to an internal police document obtained by the Chicago Tribune. His family later heard him screaming and took him to the hospital, where he died.
A coroner initially ruled that he died from natural causes, but the medical examiner’s office revisited the case at a relative’s urging and found a lethal amount of cyanide in Khan’s system.
Cyanide is among the most potent and deadly poisons, but it is not easy to get. The U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission prohibits the retail sale of products with cyanide salts. It is, however, available from industrial sources. It cleans metal and is used in research labs and mining.
Cyanide can be found in some household products, such as acetonitrile false fingernail remover. There are also tiny quantities of it in cigarette smoke, and even smaller amounts in almonds, the pits of stone fruits such as apricots and lima beans. Someone would have to eat a large quantity of those foods for it to become toxic.
“Like everything else, dose makes the poison,” said Dr. Robert Geller, medical director of the Georgia Poison Center and an associate professor at Emory University School of Medicine. He co-authored a study about cyanide poisoning and pediatric patients.
For someone to die from cyanide poisoning, he or she would have to inhale or consume a large quantity — which can cause a quick death, according to Geller.
If someone received a less severe exposure, such as through eating, the person would show early symptoms of weakness, confusion, headache, dizziness and shortness of breath. If untreated, the person could experience nausea, hypertension, vomiting, coma, seizure and then death due to cardio-respiratory arrest.
A person who has been poisoned with cyanide may take on a cherry-red coloring, and the retinal veins and arteries would appear red because the person’s cells cannot get oxygen from the blood.
In a small number of cases, a patient’s breath may smell like bitter almonds due to the excretion of unmetabolized cyanide, but more often than not it’s undetectable, according to Geller.
“In terms of intentional poisonings, you don’t have a lot of that with cyanide,” Geller said. The Georgia Poison Center has handled more than 800,000 cases of poisoning, he said, and cyanide rarely turned up in those cases.
There is an antidote kit (PDF) available for cyanide, but doctors treating Khan would have had to suspect cyanide early in his treatment to use it.
“Because it is so rare and is used so infrequently, the medical profession may have a difficult time recognizing cyanide poisoning,” Geller said.
The same is true after death. Scientists don’t usually test for cyanide in the battery of toxicology tests they may run in a suspicious death and don’t generally look for it unless there is a reason to suspect it.
Plus, there’s an economic factor. “The harder you want to find something, the more expensive it is, and this country’s forensic labs run on a shoestring budget,” Geller said.
Even knowing that Khan was poisoned, it may be difficult to determine how the cyanide got there. “Cyanide does break down in the body fairly quickly, so they may not find much,” Geller said.
“Now that he’s been buried and embalmed, you don’t have the ideal situation,” said Dr. Daniel J. Spitz, a forensic pathologist and toxicologist and the chief medical examiner for Michigan’s Macomb and St. Clair counties.
Spitz has co-authored the book “Medicolegal Investigations of Death,” considered the bible of forensic pathology that pathologists worldwide use.
“If this were me, I’d be hoping with an autopsy every other cause of death is rejected,” Spitz said. “You don’t want to have a competing cause of death when you present your case in court.”
In this next step in the investigation, scientists will examine Khan’s brain, the liver and even solid organs to try and detect the presence of cyanide so they have more than one test showing it’s what killed him — and a better sense of how it was introduced into his body.
“Many people think, with this kind of poisoning being rare and something that may not be seen, that this would be a murder someone could get away with,” Geller said. “But clearly it is not, since they did figure out this was cyanide, and there is a very good likelihood someone will get caught.”